Investors may notice that wedged between the daily share price
and bond market data in most newspapers is a growing list of
so-called hybrid securities, or hybrids.
Broadly, a hybrid security is anything that combines the
characteristics of debt (fixed interest) and equity (shares).
They are issued by companies as a way of raising money and
generally pay a predictable (fixed or floating) rate of return or
dividend for a set period, usually until a maturity or conversion
date. Investors may then have the option of converting the
securities into the underlying share or cash, or resetting for
another term. The company issuing the security will determine the
specific terms of the conversion.
The most common types of hybrids are income securities and
convertible and converting preference shares.
Some issues will be similar to pure debt and others very similar
to pure equity but there is a lot in between, says Steve Johnson,
head of research at The Intelligent Investor. He says changes to
what a company can classify as debt as well as strong investor
demand for income-generating securities has led to substantial
growth in the sector.
"Hybrids are attractive to many investors because they offer a
regular income stream and a bit more security than an ordinary
[share]," he says.
That said, they do come with their own risks. The key to these
investments is the quality of the asset, which will be reflected by
the credit rating and the financial abilities of the company to
repay the interest payments as well as the capital on maturity or
conversion.
In the event of a company collapse, hybrids rank behind senior
debt investors but above equity investors.
Income securities
When it comes to labelling, the marketing departments of many of
the companies issuing income securities appear to have had some fun
in generating acronyms. Examples are the Santos Ltd FUELS (franked,
unsecured, equity-listed securities) and the Ramsay Health Care
CARES (Convertible Adjustable Rate Equity Securities).
Few issues will be identical but some of the characteristics
will be similar, including: franking (whether the company has paid
any of the tax on the dividend); converting or convertible; fixed
or floating; resettable; cumulative or non-cumulative, redeemable;
secured and a discount on conversion to ordinary shares.
The terms convertible or converting relates to whether an income
security becomes another form of stock, usually an ordinary share,
at fixed points in time. Often it will be five years after the
instrument is issued.
Converting means that at the maturity date (or conversion date),
the security will convert into ordinary shares. Convertible means
the investor or the company issuing the security has the option of
redeeming to cash or converting to shares.
Fixed or floating refers to the interest rate applying to the
payments you receive on your investment, similar to your home loan
or bank deposits.
A reset feature means the fixed interest rate will be reviewed
at the end of a set period (usually every five years) to take
account of interest rate movements.
Cumulative refers to what occurs to any payments that are missed
if the issuing company is under financial pressure.
If the security is cumulative, any missed payments will have to
be paid before ordinary shareholders get a cut. If non-cumulative,
any missed payments are gone forever.
Some income securities are secured over specific assets, or
sometimes the entire company.
As with any secured loan, the investor is likely to receive a
lower payment as a trade-off for the additional security.
Redeemable refers to whether the issuer has a right to buy back
or redeem the instrument at a future time at a set price.
"Redeemable is a very important point as often the price that
the instrument can be redeemed at is less than the current price,"
says Johnson.
Risk
No investment is totally without risk. In the case of hybrids,
two important considerations are the impact of rising interest
rates and default risk. The market price of traded hybrid
securities or other debt instruments is sensitive to movements in
interest rates as well as other factors dealing with the
creditworthiness of the issuer and the underlying equity or
share.
When interest rates rise, hybrid securities may see a weaker
market price. As fixed rates rise for a particular investment term,
the underlying price of the security will fall so that the overall
return to an investor is equivalent to the new higher rates in the
marketplace.
As we are seeing in the current debate about whether the Reserve
Bank will act to rein in inflation, expectations about inflation
are a powerful influence on interest rates. Expectations of higher
inflation pull interest rates higher and vice versa.
Another important consideration is issuer default. The best
measure of default risk is the credit quality of the issuer, where
the higher the rating (by agencies such as Standard & Poor's
and Moody's) the better. The higher the credit quality of the
issuer, the lower the perceived risk of issuer default.
Confidence returns
Recent turmoil in the financial markets has not been lost on the
hybrid security sector, with many issues particularly vulnerable to
the tight credit markets.
However, with the overseas financial markets showing signs of
calm and new offers returning to the market, hybrids may again be
on the radar of income focused investors.
John Wong, investment analyst with researcher van Eyk, points to
the recent Suncorp preference share offer - with a yield of close
to 11 per cent - as an example of restored confidence in the
sector.
He expects other banks to start issuing hybrids, such as income
securities, which can pay tax effective returns of up to 3 percent
above the official cash rate. He says access to franking credits
and companies with investment grade credit risk has made many
hybrids an attractive option for income investors.
The hype
PROS
- Higher income yields compared with bonds reflecting the higher
risk associated with these securities.
- Opportunity to participate in the company through the share
conversion option.
- Some downside protection if an option for cash back at issue
value is offered.
- Potential tax benefits from franking credits.
CONS
- Ranks behind traditional debt obligations but ranks ahead of
equity.
- The issuer's capacity to meet its financial obligations and
other balance sheet fundamentals must be a consideration.
- Interest rate movements may affect the value.
- Price movements of the ordinary share may have a positive or
negative impact.