The increasing likelihood of cuts to interest rates, perhaps
even as early as next month, may not be enough to turn the property
market around.
Australian Property Monitors house price data for the June
quarter show falls of 2.1 per cent in Sydney and 0.6 per cent in
Melbourne.
House prices are likely to come under further pressure as the
combined effect of official rate rises and increases by lenders
bites.
"The Australian property market has defied gravity for a long
time and I think that gravity is now starting to get the upper hand
and we are starting to see prices come down," says Shane Oliver,
the chief economist at AMP Capital Investors.
The Reserve Bank has increased rates to 7.25 per cent, a 12-year
high, to slow the economy and keep inflation in check.
Lenders have also added about 0.5 percentage points on top of
this to their mortgage rates. They say they have had to do this
because of higher borrowing costs as a result of the global credit
crunch. Most standard variable mortgage rates are now above 9 per
cent.
Lower auction clearance rates and lower sales turnover also
point to continued weakness in the housing sector.
Approvals to build new homes are down by almost 8 per cent
nationally in the year to June, although there were big variations
between the states.
Australia has a shortage of up to 40,000 homes - as a result of
fewer houses being built and a growing population driven by record
migration levels - which led many economists to expect house prices
to hold steady. However, high borrowing costs are outweighing the
positives.
Rising rents are not sufficient to entice investors back into
the property market.
Australian Property Monitors data show "asking" rents for Sydney
houses increased 8 per cent in the June quarter to a weekly median
of $420 - the highest of any capital city.
For the year to June, rents for Sydney and Darwin houses rose 15
per cent, and in Melbourne and Perth rents rose 17 per cent.
Property investors tend to favour units over houses and the
rental growth for units has not been as strong as for houses. Rents
for Sydney units in the June quarter were 4 per cent higher and 11
per cent higher for the year to June. Rents for units in Melbourne
were 3 per cent higher in the June quarter and 13 per cent higher
for the year.
Louis Christopher, the founder of SQM Research, says the "rental
crisis", particularly in Sydney, is easing but it is still "tight"
at the cheaper end of the market, with a similar pattern in
Melbourne.
Christopher says the national rate for city vacancies was 2.9
per cent in June; the Sydney figure was 3.6 per cent and Melbourne
2.6 per cent. Vacancy rates of about 3 per cent are regarded as
indicating a balanced market, where rents rise in line with
inflation.
Despite a reasonable supply of rental property in Australia's
two biggest cities, rising rents and rising yields for property
investors, the increasing cost of borrowing has reduced purchasing
power.
Christopher expects property prices in Sydney and Melbourne will
be "flat" over the rest of the year. However, he says, the full
effect of the credit crunch will be felt next year.
If interest rates remain steady until Christmas, Christopher
says Sydney and Melbourne house prices could fall by between 10 and
15 per cent in 2009.
He says the falls will not be as great if the Reserve Bank cuts
interest rates. The economy is slowing, inflation is lower and the
market is now factoring in a September rate cut.
But a single cut is unlikely to make much difference to property
markets, as mortgage rates will still be high and, in any case,
lenders may not hand on the entire cut to borrowers.
Some economists, however, think there could be two or three rate
cuts next year.
Scott Haslem, the Australasian chief economist at UBS, is
"mildly optimistic" that the combination of flat or modestly lower
house prices, higher rents and falling interest rates will
encourage property investors into the market, which should help
create a floor for house prices.
Savanth Sebastian, an equities economist at Commonwealth
Securities, sees a silver lining in the doom and gloom. "Demand is
outweighing supply, by far, and you have migration growing at the
fastest level in 18 years," he says.
He is forecasting rents to rise nationally by 10 per cent during
this financial year. He thinks house prices will start to rise in
response to the Reserve Bank cutting rates or even if the bank
makes it clear to the market that rates are going to stay on
hold.
Angie Zigomanis, a research analyst at BIS Shrapnel, says there
may be "scope for more falls [in house prices] over the next six
months" but he is "more positive" about next year. If interest
rates were to come down, that could be a "ray of sunshine"
particularly in Sydney where owner-occupiers and investors have
been "battered so much and that might get them coming back into the
market".
He says even if rates do fall they are unlikely to come down by
much and houses will still to be unaffordable for many.
Zigomanis says eventually people are going to have to adjust
their expectations. "They may have to consider an apartment rather
than a house or moving two or three suburbs out from where they
ideally would like to buy," he says.