What's new?
Last week's full-year profit result from Commonwealth Bank
highlighted the strength of the Australian banking sector relative
to its international peers. Provisions for bad loans doubled from
last year to $930 million but the bank still managed to record an
underlying net profit of $4.7 billion. But growth is slowing.
Profits grew just 7 per cent from last year and, taking into
account the lower tax rate paid by the bank this year, profit
growth was only 4 per cent. More importantly, second-half growth
was lower than the first half.
The CBA's main profit engine is its retail banking services,
which account for about 40 per cent of total profits. But the
division would not have contributed any profit growth at all this
year if not for a large increase in retail deposits. Banks love
strong deposit growth because deposits are a cheap source of
funding. And in this environment, the more sources of cheap
funding, the better.
Despite CBA's robust deposit base, the bank's net interest
margin - a key measure of profitability - is under pressure.
The net interest margin represents the difference between what
the bank earns on funds lent and what it pays to borrow those
funds. The underlying net interest margin fell 10 basis points over
the year, from 2.08 per cent to 1.98 per cent.
Overall profitability, as measured by return on equity, fell
from 21.7 per cent to 20.4 per cent.
The bottom line is that the bank is holding up well in tough
times but its profitability is declining.
Outlook
CBA chief executive Ralph Norris is not overly sanguine about
the future, saying the present global banking crisis could play out
for years. This means the bank's profitability is likely to remain
under pressure for some time. Due to the deleveraging taking place
in the global economy, the strong credit growth that has fuelled
banks' profits in recent years is likely to remain at subdued
levels for some time to come. Given its large exposure to housing,
CBA will be hoping the local property market can avoid the pain
occurring in nearly all other overvalued property markets around
the world. If recent price falls are just the start of things to
come, CBA and the banking sector in general will have a new round
of problems to deal with.
Price
CBA's share price peaked at more than $60 late last year. At the
time the general consensus was Australian banks were insulated from
the global credit market turmoil. Then one day investors woke up
and realised the banks were indeed exposed. The shares went over a
cliff and, from a high of more than $60, fell to about $37 in a
matter of months. The stock has since rebounded and is
consolidating between the March low and about $45.
Worth buying?
Many people believe the banks are cheap. If you believe credit
growth will return to 2006 levels in a hurry, then banks are indeed
cheap. But that's not going to happen. CBA is trading at a fair
value. Taking into account the slowing domestic economy and rising
bad debt cycle, the profit outlook looks risky. The dividend, at
about 6.5 per cent, is attractive but we'd be avoiding the stock
for now.